How to Challenge the Food Police
If you’ve ever heard a voice in your head saying “I shouldn’t be eating this,” “This is bad,” or “I need to make up for this later,” you’ve encountered the food police. The food police are not actual people. They are internalized beliefs, rules, and judgments about food that come from diet culture, wellness trends, family messages, and past experiences. These thoughts tell us what we should or should not eat, often wrapped up in morality, fear, and shame.
Challenging the food police is not about eating perfectly or silencing every critical thought overnight. It is about loosening the grip of rigid food rules so food takes up less mental space and eating can feel more neutral, flexible, and supportive.
What are the Food Police?
The food police are diet-culture-driven thoughts that label foods as good or bad, healthy or unhealthy, clean or junk, allowed or off-limits. They often show up automatically and sound convincing, even when they increase stress rather than support well-being.
Common food police thoughts include:
“I was bad for eating that.”
“I need to earn this food.”
“I already messed up today, so what’s the point?”
“I should be more disciplined.”
“I can’t trust myself around this food.”
These thoughts are not a personal failure. They are learned. And because they are learned, they can be challenged.
Why the Food Police are so Loud
The food police thrive in a culture that praises control, thinness, productivity, and optimization. Food is often framed as something to manage, track, or restrict rather than something that nourishes, satisfies, and supports daily life.
When food is moralized:
Eating becomes stressful instead of supportive
Guilt and shame increase
Restrict and binge cycles are reinforced
Trust in the body erodes
Even when the goal is health, fear-based food rules often backfire. Instead of improving health, they increase anxiety around eating and make it harder to listen to internal cues.
How to Challenge the Food Police
Challenging the food police does not mean arguing with yourself or forcing positive thoughts. It means creating space between you and the rule so you can respond with intention rather than reflex.
1. Name the Thought
Instead of getting pulled into “I am bad for eating this,” try reframing it as:
“This is a food police thought.”
Naming the thought helps externalize it. It reminds you that this is a belief, not a fact.
2. Get Curious Instead of Critical
Rather than judging yourself for having the thought, ask gentle questions:
Where did I learn this rule?
What is this rule trying to protect me from?
Is this thought helping me feel calmer or more anxious?
Curiosity reduces shame. Criticism reinforces it.
3. Separate Food From Morality
Food does not have moral value. Eating a certain food does not make you good or bad, disciplined or out of control.
Try shifting language toward neutrality:
Replace “junk food” with the actual name of the food
Replace “I was bad” with “I ate something I enjoy”
Neutral language creates room for choice instead of judgment.
4. Notice the Fear Behind the Rule
Most food rules exist to prevent something perceived as dangerous, such as weight gain, loss of control, judgment from others, or physical discomfort.
Ask yourself:
What does this rule say will happen if I break it?
Is that threat happening right now?
What happens when I follow this rule long term?
Often, the rule promises safety but creates stress.
5. Practice Gentle Permission
Challenging the food police is not about eating everything all at once. It is about knowing you are allowed to eat a food, even if you decide not to in that moment.
Gentle permission sounds like:
“I am allowed to eat this.”
“I can have this again later.”
“There is no urgency.”
Permission reduces urgency. Restriction increases it.
6. Expect the Thoughts to Push Back
When you begin loosening food rules, the food police often get louder before they quiet down.
This does not mean you are doing something wrong. It means you are interrupting a familiar pattern.
You do not need to eliminate food police thoughts to make progress. You only need to stop letting them dictate your choices.
When the Food Police Show Up After Eating
Post-eating guilt is one of the most common ways the food police show up.
Instead of trying to fix or undo what you ate, focus on regulation:
Take a few slow breaths
Place your feet on the floor
Remind yourself that eating is allowed and your body knows how to process food
No compensating. No punishment. Just support.
Challenging the Food Police is a Practice
This work is not linear. Some days the food police are quieter. Other days they feel loud and persistent.
Progress may look like:
Noticing the thought sooner
Responding with less intensity
Recovering more quickly from guilt
You do not need perfect trust with food to move toward a more peaceful relationship with eating.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Food Police
-
The food police refers to internalized diet culture thoughts that judge food and eating behaviors as good or bad. These thoughts often create guilt, fear, or anxiety around eating and can interfere with a healthy relationship with food.
-
Yes! Challenging the food police does not mean ignoring health. It means shifting away from fear-based rules and toward a more flexible, sustainable approach that supports both physical and mental well-being.
-
There is no set timeline. For many people, progress looks like noticing food police thoughts sooner, responding with less intensity, and recovering more quickly from guilt rather than eliminating the thoughts entirely.
-
Not necessarily. Many people experience food police thoughts because diet culture is pervasive. However, when these thoughts become frequent, distressing, or lead to restriction, bingeing, or anxiety around food, additional support can be helpful.
You Do Not Have to Do This Alone
If food police thoughts feel constant, overwhelming, or tied to anxiety, binge eating, restriction, or fear around food, support can help.
Working with a weight-inclusive, non-diet dietitian can help you unpack food rules, rebuild trust with your body, and create a more regulated relationship with food without shame or rigidity.
If you are ready for support, we are here.
